The first half or so has a good bit of flashbacks, with the main character thinking back to the past, in a very disturbing and worrying fashion. The story is compelling, powerful and incredibly moving. Kantorek, Lew Ayres, Louis Wolheim, Maxwell Anderson, Erich Maria Remarque. Great adaptation of superb anti-war classic, Excellent remake of the Lewis Milestone classic, A Double Rarity: A Good Remake & A Good Made For TV Movie, One of the Few WWI films around and very good at that. 1930s one is far superior in my opinion. This movie conveys that very effectivly. Retrying. Paul eventually spends the night in a shell hole with a dying French soldier (whom he stabbed). All Quiet on the Western Front, full text.pdf. A young soldier faces profound disillusionment in the soul-destroying horror of World War I. Everyone. All Quiet on the Western Front (1979) ... That is not the case with this remake of one of the greatest all time war movies "All Quiet on the Western Front" which came out in the 1930s in black and white. Definitely recommended. In addition the gloomy skies, constant rain, mud all add to the sense of tragedy and betrayal. Check out the exclusive TVGuide.com movie review and see our movie rating for All Quiet On The Western Front. His shaved head and Goatee give him a great period look. Machine guns mow down lines of men. This movie is so close to being a masterpiece that it's too bad that it falls just a little short. The acting is very good, none of the major roles disappoint. All Quiet on the Western Front is a movie based on the book of the same name by Erich Maria Remarque published in 1929. Erich Maria Remarque’s All Quiet on the Western Front is an abstruse proclamation against war, which focuses especially on the destroying effects of war on soldiers’ humanity. The pacing is good, but it drags a little at some points, and there are too many scenes that seem less important than they should. Soldiers trip over barbed wire, shredding their flesh in the process. This is the story of innocence lost, of life and the unbelievable changes that occur when a person is exposed to death on the scale that World War I produced. Romantic ideals of warfare are under attack throughout Paul’s narration. With Richard Thomas, Ernest Borgnine, Donald Pleasence, Ian Holm. I particularly like the portrayals of Himmelstoss and Kat; Ernest Borgnine is outstanding in his role. It took author Erich Maria Remarque two years to find a publisher for his novel about the defeat of the German Army in World War I. Remarque himself had fought in the trenches and been wounded, so he knew whereof he wrote. Hardly anyone would watch this when they can see the original instead - a film with a more famous pedigree. The director doesn't shove the belief of war being pointless and devastating physically, spiritually and psychologically down our throat... he merely shows it as it is, and lets us decide/discover for ourself. Why this is I haven't been able to find out but was missing is important plot info that makes many scenes understandable. A Review of "Western" Number 2 (The TV Movie), Powerful and moving... the definitive anti-war war movie. Just an interesting aside is the appearance of Patricia Neal as the young soldier, Paul's, mother. Patricia Neal portrayed Olivia Walton in the pilot episode of THE WALTONS (THE HOMECOMING); so it was interesting to see she and Thomas as mother and son again. There was a problem previewing All Quiet on the Western Front, full text.pdf. I believe you, but I can't help asking myself how many of you really have seen the original version? Himmelstosse. "All Quiet on the Western Front" 1930 vs. 1979. There are main differences from 1930 version but it is not meaningful to compare. 8/10. Many of the major tragic events in the first half are made even worse when you see the flashback related to it. I believe the old 1930 original is a *slightly* better film, but this is overall an excellent remake. Is it worth it after seeing the 1979 one? Gradually the grinding attrition of war eliminates Paul's classmates and the old sweats, until the famous final scene, when so little happened that day that the war entry was "All quiet on the Western Front." With Richard Thomas, Ernest Borgnine, Donald Pleasence, Ian Holm. The 1979 TV movie is true to the novel, whereas the 1930 movie is not, although they are both very powerful films. That is not the case with this remake of one of the greatest all time war movies "All Quiet on the Western Front" which came out in the 1930s in black and white. I was rather young when this first aired on American TV in 1978-79ish I was in the sixth grade and this was the first war movie which really made an impression on me. I do not agree with any of the reviews posted here. The novel was published in 1929 and soon after in 1930 the film “All Quiet on the Western Front” followed, which was a faithful adaptation of the novel. External Reviews Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Submissions and comments should be on topics related to this subject except when otherwise permitted. It's curious that that horrifying and mis-managed war and its humiliating peace agreement generated disparate reactions in Germany. This 1979 remake of Lewis Milestones 1930 classic anti war film tells the story of German youths who enlist in the Kaisers army to fight for the Fatherland in the great war. I remembered watching this film in college and got it for my daughter when she was studying WWI. Naturally very few people watch message movies. I thought it was a fantastic production. The cinematography is good, but there were times where it could have been better(see The Thin Red Line for a good example). It is a great story and very well-acted. And yet, this 1979 television remake of the Lewis Milestone original adds many elements to cherish of its own. Many people make the mistake of thinking of this movie as a remake of the 1930 film classic. I haven't seen the '79 version. It's gonna be based on the book, but follows an original script and story. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_Quiet_on_the_Western_Front_(1930_film) All Quiet on the Western Front (1930) is the first major anti-war film of the sound era, faithfully based upon the timeless, best-selling 1929 novel by Erich Maria Remarque (who had experienced the war first-hand as a young German soldier). All Quiet on the Western Front. A young soldier faces profound disillusionment in the soul-destroying horror of World War I. Over 80 years after its release, the film is still very effective, and ranks among the genres finest works. I saw the original many years ago and the scenes that stuck out in my mind most are recreated here . Read Common Sense Media's All Quiet on the Western Front review, age rating, and parents guide. | Still tugs my heartstrings when I watch it. The film is an excellent remake. | Though in some ways it doesn't live up to the 1930 original, there are some other ways in which I think it is more effective. It shows exactly how rotten, pointless and devastating to humanity and creativity war really is. Even by today's standards, the battles scenes are super gruesome, even with black-and-white blood. But it is always the young generation that does the dying, whilst the old men discuss strategy over a beer. The characters are well-written, credible and human. One of Paul’s classmates who serves with Paul in the Second Company. I haven't seen the first movie, so would love to hear what others say on the topic. Some parts of this version are better than the original and in others the 1930 version still stands out. With successors like Das Boot and Saving Private Ryan, it also seems less visionary now. ALREADY the source of a film classic, made 50 years ago, Erich Maria Remarque's “All Quiet on the Western Front” has now been adapted for television. The made for TV and 'remake' labels have tended to devalue All Quiet on the Western Front. I have since seen the the original 1920's version with Lou Ayers and Louis Wholheim. I remember reading it nearly two decades ago and its still one of the best books I've ever read. The remake is more intelligent, the cast is great and the period detail is extraordinary. Most of the scenes in the original are presented here, a few additions and a couple deletions. This shows that you don't have to display graphic violence, deafen your audience with loud, noisy heavy metal or throw in plot twists to shock your audience; you can show something that the general public is oblivious of, such as war in it's purest and most uncensored form. It does a very good job of capturing the book which is to show the war from a common man's point of view. The most powerful message of the movie, in my opinion, is that there are no "good" or "bad" guys in war - there's just you and someone else who is out to kill you. I know that many people over here think this movie isn't as good as the original one from 1930. Yea, they said they're probably gonna write a new storyline and everything though. They're befriended by and old hand, ably played by Ernest Borgnine, who teaches them how to stay alive in that awful conflict. Sign In. The battle scenes are breathlessly exciting; and yet they do not dwell on carnage, and it is to their credit...and yet still they elicit pity and horror from the viewer. “The landmark, epic film, made on a large-scale budget of $1.25 million, was an Academy Award winner for … Donald Pleasence has a rather small part but is really great as the nationalistic school teacher who chastises Baumer's idleness and romanticism. I barely glared at the first few seconds of it, uninterested and expecting a mediocre, dull and cliché-ridden war film, but was immediately captured by the purity of the film and the lack of pretension. The very end is so devastating and horrifying that no one can possibly see it without being affected. Unexaggerate but impressive exposition gives many messages about the meaningless of big war and leaves permanent tracks on minds. Where as in my memory the scenes of a wounded comrade missing a limb not realising his friend wants his boots and where Paul lies in a shell hole with a dying enemy seem clichéd due to similar scenes being reused down the decades the same scenes here stand up very well on their hind legs. It shows how the young and naive are being brain-washed to think that somehow it is their duty to kill and die. It is also definitely an anti-war film. I … I didn't cry, watching this movie, but had I not looked away during the most disturbing sequences and possessed an almost insurmountable amount of self-control, I would have. In 1930, the book was adapted as an Academy-Award-winning film of the same name, directed by Lewis Milestone. I recommend All Quiet on the Western Front(1979)(TV)to any person who wants something special from a movie besides of just spending time. Directed by Delbert Mann. Hungry, dirty, seeing all your friends die, etc. An intelligent, … With a new version of the story coming on to the big screen in late 2014, I was wondering which one you guys preferred? It shows good attention to historical detail. | All Quiet on the Western Front, full text.pdf. None of them are heroes or villains. This is a very good anti-war movie. The guy that wrote the book lived through the war but all his friends were killed. There was additional footage when the it first aired in 1978-79 and it has always been cut short when it has subsequently been aired on TV since then, but I do recall scenes such as Baumer narrating the first time his unit encountered flamethrowers on the western front and the scene in which he and his friends tease and taunt a seemingly innocuous Mailman on their way to enlist in the German Army and that Mailman turns out to be Cpl. All Quiet On The Western Front Synopsis: This is an English language film (made in America) adapted from a novel by German author Erich Maria Remarque. I recently watched the TV version of "All Quiet on the Western Front" from 1979. 1930; 2 HR 20 MIN; NR; ... ALL QUIET ON THE WESTERN FRONT is perhaps the greatest antiwar film ever made, holding considerable power even now due to … It seems folly when a television company remakes a well regarded film but ITC Films have made a considerable achievement with their remake of ALL QUIET ON THE WESTERN FRONT . The Blue Max Captain Kidd From Noon Till Three Flying Tigers The Professionals. "All Quiet On The Western Front" had a huge impact on me. Recreation of a Western Front battlefield demonstrating weapons, dangers and tactics. Changes to the original are minor - Paul, for example, as an artist, drawing a bird in the final scene rather than reaching for a butterfly - and do not in any way detract from the power of Remarque's story. It won great praise in the United States but was banned in several other countries, including Germany , because of its pacifist message. The film follows a group of German schoolboys, talked into enlisting at the beginning of World War 1 by their jingoistic teacher. Donald Pleasance is excellent as Paul's patriotic teacher who exhorts Paul and his classmates to enlist. It's a time when they have their entire promising lives ahead of them and they are stuffed full of patriotic slogans and propaganda about glorious sacrifice for the "Fatherland". I haven't seen the original film yet. Directed by Delbert Mann. It is without question the greatest war novel ever written. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Hitler's attitude won, of course, and it was then claimed that Remarque's real name was Kramer, a Jewish name, which Remarque had spelled backwards to disguise his ethnic identity. Based on the masterful novel by Erich Maria Remarque the youths who join at the encouragement of their schoolteacher with dreams of glory quickly learn the horror of war. Where to watch. If you're in the US, the 1930 version is on Turner Classic Movies tomorrow night (Feb 15) at 8pm Eastern. The 1979 TV movie is true to the novel, whereas the 1930 movie is not, although they are both very powerful films. ... 1974 The Godfather II 1975 One Flew Over the Cukoo's Nest 1976 Rocky 1977 Annie Hall 1978 The Deer Hunter 1979 Kramer vs. Kramer. FAQ This was very, very good. The great actress, Patricia Neal, shines in a cameo as Paul's mother. A classic anti war film, All Quiet on the Western Front is a masterwork of filmmaking. War has lost whatever legitimacy it ever may have had when the leaders left the front line to lead from the back, safe in their headquarters miles away from the killing. In reality, both movies are a visual telling of the 1929 novel by the same name; at different points in time. Awards this is strictly made for TV.However, having said that, one would have to put it up there among one of the finest that the tube has had to offer over the last 25 years or so. This subreddit is dedicated to the discussion of the history, art, culture and commemoration of World War One (1914-1918). His life would make a great movie. I thought it was a fantastic production. The director - Delbert Mann - is an experienced veteran with classics like Marty to his credit. All Quiet On The Western Front. The Nazi's hated him so he couldn't go back to Germany until after WWII but as you look at the movie it's amazing the guy's life turned out like it did. I recommend this film to just about anyone who believe they can manage to sit through it... everyone should see it. It was good and featured ground breaking sound quality at a time when movies had only recently begun using sound, but I really liked this remake. Some get their come-uppance, such as Cpl Himmelstoss, but most live their lives in the comfortable cocoon of their self-righteousness the school teacher, the father, the Kaiser himself. WW1 is without a doubt the most tragic war ever fought. | Ernest Borgnine is terrific as Kat, the cagey survivor, who takes the youngsters under his wing, teaching them ways to make trench warfare almost tolerable. Fewer still would make the effort to rent a "made for TV" film. This 1979 film is just a retelling of that story, and it's obvious from its differences from the 1930 film. All Quiet on the Western Front is a 1930 American epic Pre-Code war film based on the Erich Maria Remarque novel of the same name. If you want a film to move you and make you think about life, look out for this one in your video store. This movie really took advantage of a great opportunity: Teaming Richard Thomas and Ernst Borgnine while they were both still young enough for the parts! Then there was Remarque, who represented the other path, which could be roughly summarized as, "It was pretty lousy. Years after directing the classic Marty (1955), Delbert Mann became a creator of prestige TV movie projects, none more daunting than his adaptation of All Quiet on the Western Front (1979). ... All Quiet On The Western Front. The remake is better! With a new version of the story coming on to the big screen in late 2014, I was wondering which one you guys preferred? All Quiet on the Western Front izle, Batı Cephesinde Yeni Bir Şey Yok - izle, 720p izle, 1080p hd izle, filmin bilgileri, konusu, oyuncuları, tüm serileri bu sayfada.. It deserves more than just a TV movie specially after seeing supposedly big budget anti-war movies.In addition this picture has one of the best unexpected and shocking ending in the movie history in my opinion. Albert Kropp. In short: there's a whole lot of weaponry on display in All Quiet on the Western Front. The novel, published in 1929 by the 31 yr old Remarque was an instant classic. All Quiet on the Western Front sold 2.5 million copies in 22 languages in its first 18 months in print. Thomas is wonderful, as he always is; but it's Borgnine you remember most as the old soldier, Kat. His characterisation is wonderfully profound, and poignant, and the scene in the trench with the French soldier is a virtual masterclass of compassionate acting. I was incredibly moved by this film, and deeply affected. By JOHN J. O'CONNOR. I read All Quiet On The Western Front while serving in the U.S. Marines in Vietnam, 1966-1967. It was sufficiently depressing to facilitate the theme of the "Lost Generation" or perhaps better the "Betrayed Generation" groomed for military service as soon as they graduated high school. One of my all time favourites - considering that it was just a TV film makes its even more astonishing. Richard Thomas was perfect as the boy who finds out what war is really like. It makes more sense when you later see how cruel and authoritarian Himmelstosse is when he becomes their drill instructor. Not the director's version as shown on TV, "Soft" remake no comparison to the original. Classic anti-war epic tells dire, exhausting tale. One of the previous postings brings up the point of the "missing footage" He/She is right!!! Granted I've never seen the original - I do have that unfortunate problem of being unable to relate to films made in a very young time. All Quiet on the Western Front is a television movie produced by ITC Entertainment, released on November 14, 1979, starring actors Richard Thomas from The Waltons fame as Paul Baumer, and Ernest Borgnine as Katczinsky. Personally I like this version better...it's not overacted, it was filmed on location, it has a musical score, and it has a feeling of reality to it that the 1930 film just doesn't seem to have. Most notably, the casting of Richard Thomas, best known for being John-Boy Walton, in the role of Richard Baume. Or is it because you know this is 'just' a remake? This is the story of a young German soldier named Paul (Richard Thomas) and his classmates, who join the German Army in World War One. He drifted from job to job, had trouble sleeping, etc, what they call now post-trauma, then to get the stuff out of his head he wrote it down in 1929. I had heard that it was realistic and powerful, but I wasn't quite sure that I actually believed it. The Director/Producer also did a very good job with small details such as the transition from the more decorative "spiked" helmets of 1914-16 to the flared steel helmets of 1916-18. The part that intrigues me the most about it, is that fact that it was made before WW2 even happened. Then boom! The color cinematography is nicely done. 1979, War, 2h 36m. It is difficult to go wrong with such a magnificent story, one of the most affecting literary anatomisations of the tragedy of young men destroyed by war. The VHS video of All Quiet is good but it is missing about 30 minutes of the original as shown on Tv. Everyone is equal, which is exactly what it is like in real life, in war. The Hollywood adaptation starring Lew Ayres - director Lewis Milestones greatest achievement - was very good as testified by its IMDb status. Richard Thomas is very good, if about ten years too old, as the central character, Paul Baumer, who grows from glory seeking school boy to crusty veteran to, finally disillusioned, weary, almost hopeless pawn. Considering this was made in 1979, this is quiet an astonishing film, that is incredibly realistic in its portrayal of the futility of combat in world war one. User Ratings Stronger characters and the horrors of the war are more apparent. This film makes no attempt to glorify war and is brutally honest about it's effect on those who are left alive after months or years of bitter fighting. Why scenes like that are never on TV (except the original broadcast) and are not even on the video tape is beyond me. No matter how many times I've watched it, the end always leaves me feeling as if I had been a part of the story and its effects linger with my being. Well worth a look as either a comparison or companion to the 1930 original. This remake of a classic and important film attempts repeatedly to try to correct, justify, apologize for or otherwise soften scenes it lifts from the original and in doing so deprives them all of most of their meaning. Whoops! Example of a scence cut is after the Kasier awards the metal the uncut version shows the boys complaining about who recieved the metal, talking about having to remove the new uniforms so the next group will look good for the kasier, and other anti war talk/questions. Movie details. Well worth a watch! It's a bestseller, he has money, goes to Hollywood, marries a move star (Paulette Goddard) and travels around the world. "They left for war as boys, never to return as men.". Press J to jump to the feed. The first war movie that ever affected me. It was directed by Lewis Milestone, and stars Louis Wolheim, Lew Ayres, John Wray, Arnold Lucy and Ben Alexander. The most famous film version of All Quiet on the Western Front is the 1930 adaptation directed by Lewis Milestone. All Quiet is his magnum opus, released on TV because theatre owners didn't see it making any money. ดูหนังออนไลน์ All Quiet on the Western Front (1979) สนามรบ สนามชีวิต เต็มเรื่องพากย์ไทย ซับไทย ดูหนังฟรี 2020 หนัง HD เว็บไซต์ดูหนัง อันดับต้นของประเทศ v8movie.com Two things that are very tricky to do in Hollywood: After putting off watching this film for a while, mainly due to seeing a few bad war movies and quite a few mediocre ones(The Thin Red Line, The Eagle Has Landed), I finally decided to watch this. Ian Holm has a nice turn as Paul's town's postman turned training NCO, who later is transferred to the trenches. The Frenchman's death affects Paul profoundly. Big words like Fatherland, Kaiser, God, Patriotism. http://www.tcm.com/tcmdb/title/67079/All-Quiet-On-The-Western-Front/. This remake was made in the mid to late 1970s and features such stars as Richard Thomas (John Boy Walton) and Ernest Borgnine (McHale's Navy). However, All Quiet on the Western Front is a superb adaptation of Erich Maria Remarque's classic novel. I remember watching this movie when it first was broadcast in 1979. Its great to see WW1 finally making it onto the main stage. The suffering that the real soldiers went through in WW1 is powerfully conveyed in this film. Beautiful symbolism. Sending young boys to their death whilst claiming it is eventually for the Good is the ultimate cowardice. Overall, a very good remake of the old classic. The plot is very good, and the way it's told is great. Kudos the makeup and costuming people. In my estimation it is one of the best TV-movies ever done and one of the few worthy of a theatrical release, which the movie did have in Europe. Even at that age, when I might not fully appreciate the deprivations and horrors of war, I remember thinking that it really was pretty brutal and utterly tragic how all of these men Germans, French, British, Russians, Americans were all sent to die by the thousands. Ernest Borgnine fantastic, what a great actor. It was adapted again in 1979 by Delbert Mann, this time as a television film starring Richard Thomas and Ernest Borgnine The film was advertised with the brooding face of one of the young German recruits sent into World War I. Richard Thomas (John Boy) is very good as Paul Baumer, the Romantic of the group through who's eyes we see the tragedy unfold in the muddy trenches, filthy hospitals, and countless flashbacks of his bucolic life before the war. Considering it was made for TV I thought the action and special effects were great. I recently watched the TV version of "All Quiet on the Western Front" from 1979. "Stabbed in the back" by politicians, said Hitler, who had also fought and been wounded, as he rose to power. I can say that it is the best anti-war movie released so far. Let's not do it again." The first version was released in 1930, quickly after the book was published, and was directed by Lewis Milestone. All Quiet on the Western Front is narrated by Paul Bäumer, a young man of nineteen who fights in the German army on the French front in World War I. Paul and several of his friends from school joined the army voluntarily after listening to the stirring patriotic speeches of their teacher, Kantorek.